EU seeks quantum cryptography response to Echelon

Tyler Durden camera_lumina at
Tue May 18 15:38:44 EDT 2004

Boondoggle. A solution in search of a problem:

"Monyk believes there will be a global market of several million users once
a workable solution has been developed. A political decision will have to
be taken as to who those users will be in order to prevent terrorists and
criminals from taking advantage of the completely secure communication
network, he said."

Silliness itself, at this point. Practical quantum cryptography at this 
point is limited to transmission. The moment it goes O/E, it's as vulnerable 
as any other data. And terrorists aren't going to bother splicing fiber.

Of course, primitive quantum storage (with error correcting codes!) is 
possible and done in laboratories, but we're talking tens of bits here. 
It'll be a decade before quantum storage is practical, and that's only IF 
someone can find a convincing reason to start developing it.


>From: "R. A. Hettinga" <rah at>
>To: cryptography at, cypherpunks at
>Subject: EU seeks quantum cryptography response to Echelon
>Date: Mon, 17 May 2004 14:32:34 -0400
>Network World Fusion
>EU seeks quantum cryptography response to Echelon
>By Philip Willan
>IDG News Service, 05/17/04
>The European Union is to invest ¤11 million ($13 million) over the next
>four years to develop a secure communication system based on quantum
>cryptography, using physical laws governing the universe on the smallest
>scale to create and distribute unbreakable encryption keys, project
>coordinators said Monday.
>  If successful, the project would produce the cryptographer's holy grail 
>absolutely unbreakable code -- and thwart the eavesdropping efforts of
>espionage systems such as Echelon, which intercepts electronic messages on
>behalf of the intelligence services of the U.S., the U.K., Canada, New
>Zealand and Australia.
>  "The aim is to produce a communication system that cannot be intercepted
>by anyone, and that includes Echelon," said Sergio Cova, a professor from
>the electronics department of Milan Polytechnic and one of the project's
>coordinators. "We are talking about a system that requires significant
>technological innovations. We have to prove that it is workable, which is
>not the case at the moment." Major improvements in geographic range and
>speed of data transmission will be required before the system becomes a
>commercial reality, Cova said.
>  "The report of the European Parliament on Echelon recommends using 
>cryptography as a solution to electronic eavesdropping. This is an effort
>to cope with Echelon," said Christian Monyk, the director of quantum
>technologies at the Austrian company ARC Seibersdorf Research and overall
>coordinator of the project. Economic espionage has caused serious harm to
>European companies in the past, Monyk said. "With this project we will be
>making an essential contribution to the economic independence of Europe."
>  Quantum cryptography takes advantage of the physical properties of light
>particles, known as photons, to create and transmit binary messages. The
>angle of vibration of a photon as it travels through space -- its
>polarization -- can be used to represent a zero or a one under a system
>first devised by scientists Charles Bennett and Gilles Brassard in 1984. It
>has the advantage that any attempt to intercept the photons is liable to
>interfere with their polarization and can therefore be detected by those
>operating the system, the project coordinators said. An intercepted key
>would therefore be discarded and a new one created for use in its place.
>  The new system, known as SECOQC (Secure Communication based on Quantum
>Cryptography), is intended for use by the secure generation and exchange of
>encryption keys, rather than for the actual exchange of data, Monyk said.
>  "The encrypted data would then be transmitted by normal methods," he 
>Messages encrypted using quantum mechanics can currently be transmitted
>over optical fibers for tens of kilometers. The European project intends to
>extend that range by combining quantum physics with other technologies,
>Monyk said. "The important thing about this project is that it is not based
>solely on quantum cryptography but on a combination with all the other
>components that are necessary to achieve an economic application," he said.
>"We are taking a really broad approach to quantum cryptography, which other
>countries haven't done."
>  Experts in quantum physics, cryptography, software and network 
>from universities, research institutes and private companies in Austria,
>Belgium, Britain, Canada, the Czech Republic, Denmark, France, Germany,
>Italy, Russia, Sweden and Switzerland will be contributing to the project,
>Monyk said.
>  In 18 months project participants will assess progress on a number of
>alternative solutions and decide which technologies are the most promising
>and merit further development, project coordinators said. SECOQC aims to
>have a workable technology ready in four years, but will probably require
>three to four years of work beyond that before commercial use, Monyk said.
>  Cova was more cautious: "This is the equivalent of the first flight of 
>Wright brothers, so it is too early to be talking already about supersonic
>transatlantic travel."
>  The technological challenges facing the project include the creation of
>sensors capable of recording the arrival of photons at high speed and
>photon generators that produce a single photon at a time, Cova said. "If
>two or three photons are released simultaneously they become vulnerable to
>interception," he said.
>  Monyk believes there will be a global market of several million users 
>a workable solution has been developed. A political decision will have to
>be taken as to who those users will be in order to prevent terrorists and
>criminals from taking advantage of the completely secure communication
>network, he said.
>  "In my view it should not be limited to senior government officials and
>the military, but made available to all users who need really secure
>communications," Monyk said. Banks, insurance companies and law firms could
>be potential clients, Monyk said, and a decision will have to be made as to
>whether and how a key could be made available to law enforcement
>authorities under exceptional circumstances. "It won't be up to us to
>decide who uses our results," said Milan Polytechnic's Cova.
>R. A. Hettinga <mailto: rah at>
>The Internet Bearer Underwriting Corporation <>
>44 Farquhar Street, Boston, MA 02131 USA
>"... however it may deserve respect for its usefulness and antiquity,
>[predicting the end of the world] has not been found agreeable to
>experience." -- Edward Gibbon, 'Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire'

MSN Toolbar provides one-click access to Hotmail from any Web page – FREE 

The Cryptography Mailing List
Unsubscribe by sending "unsubscribe cryptography" to majordomo at

More information about the cryptography mailing list