[Cryptography] Finding Nemo's random seed

[Henry Baker]

At 11:38 AM 9/5/2017, Kent Borg wrote:
>On 09/05/2017 01:06 PM, John Denker via cryptography wrote:
>>-- Sometimes you want something that is entirely deterministic and predictable, just complicated-looking, e.g. sea grass.
>
>And presumably the folks writing the rendering software did know this.  The older rendering software knew how to keep track of its RNG state, so it could re-render frames without positions changing.  It is common to re-render 3D scenes and fragments of scenes as components are added, tweaked, lighting changed, eventually better quality output generated, etc.  The sea grass that Nemo is swimming through had better not jump from one rendering to another.  Someone was very aware of this.
>
>But it seems that wasn't explicit in the "source code" that they preserved for Finding Nemo.  And somehow programmers are better at writing functions for importing data than they are for exporting data...
>
>Similarly for any Monte Carlo simulation: frequently one wants to be able to rerun different version of the code on previous "random" data.

Two words: functional programming.

Another two words: no sympathy.